Skip to Content

Why Consistency is Important in Dog Training

There are no sidewalks where we live. Our country roads have narrow gravel shoulders and, most of the time, drivers going much faster than the speed limit. One of our important commands for Baxter is “over.”

Baxter prefers walking on the road—maybe he finds the gravel uncomfortable on his feet—and he doesn’t comprehend that people will not yield to him (although many drivers do swing around us).

When a car is coming, “over” is how we tell Baxter to move out of the traffic and stay safe.

However, I realize I’ve not set Baxter up for success with this command.

At its most basic, “over” means move onto the gravel as close to the grass and the ditch as you can.

In my ideal scenario, “over” also means stay in front of me (Baxter’s usual walking position) and maintain your pace.

Walking a dog with a waist leash

Baxter will do this usually for the first two times I give the “over” command during a walk. But after that, his “over” is unreliable. As I force him into the position that I want, I step in front of him and use the leash to tug him behind me and over. (With a speeding car bearing down on us, there’s not a lot of time to wait him out or negotiate.)

We’ve gotten to the point that now when I say “over” Baxter’s reaction is often to stop walking or slow down and wait to be tucked behind me. Once he’s there, we walk very slowly, sometimes engaging in tug o’ war with the leash as he tries to step back out onto the road.

This is very annoying—not to mention unsafe. I feel like Bax knows the command because he does it sometimes, but he’s too lazy or obstinate to obey all the time.

And maybe that’s true. But I also feel like I’m not being fair to Bax.

I can’t be frustrated that he’s not doing the behaviour that I want because I am not being consistent when I ask him to move “over.” Sometimes I move in front of him. Sometimes I don’t. My behaviour is not the same, so how can I expect his to be?

To teach my ideal “over,” I have to break down the steps that I want, find a calm safe spot to practice, and slowly build until Bax does it reliably. Or, I accept that “over” means I shorten the leash, move in front of Bax, tuck him behind me, and we slow our pace.

Baxter in the "over" position while walking on the road

Most important, I have to be consistent in my actions when I give the command.

I’ve decided that the best way to achieve that consistency and set Baxter up for success is to go with the second scenario for “over.” I’m prioritizing a loose leash once Baxter is behind me—no more tug o’ war—and he stays in the over position until I say “okay.”

Being thoughtful about the command and the behaviour I want has helped to decrease my frustration. I also think it’s helping with Baxter’s confusion (or obstinacy, if I’m being cynical).

Does anyone else have problems with consistency in commands? How do you ensure you’re getting the response you want from your dog?

Julia Thomson is a blogger at Home on 129 Acres where she writes about her adventures of country living and DIY renovating. She and her family live on a 129-acre farm in Ontario, Canada. Follow Julia on Instagram here.


Wednesday 7th of November 2018

Kind of very problematic, cause you know I don't even know how to train my dog hahaha and it's just that he always love to wander and explore and I kind want of locator or locate his location just you know in case. But this helps thanks a lot.

Hiking With Heather

Monday 29th of October 2018

I'm totally guilty of this too. Something to work on!

Jane Ritchuk

Monday 29th of October 2018

My 9 month old rescued Lab cross seems to think that me holding his leash is an invitation to a game of "Chase me". Its loads of fun (for him) not so much for me. I have tried starting with a sit command, even with Benny Bully it doesn't seem to work. Also, I am using a Gentle Leader which he HATES. Any ideas?

Lindsay Stordahl

Monday 29th of October 2018

It takes some dogs a long time to accept wearing a gentle leader and most don't like it. I use a treat for my dog and give command "nose in" when he wears his. He hates it, but he will wear it. He used to "buck around" with it on like a wild horse and I just ignored him and kept moving forward. If your dog doesn't seem to be doing well with it, I would try a different option like a slip collar or martingale or a no pull harness. It's nice to have a few options though and the Gentle Leader does work really well for a lot of dogs.

Janis Lamberty

Sunday 28th of October 2018

I find that my 5 month old mix pup is rock solid in predictable situations, with a sit stay but as soon as there is another dog (or our neighbors cat) she breaks! Do I need to start with her right next to me in the driveway with the cat in the distance and then work my way forward from there? She wants that cat sooooo bad!!!

Lindsay Stordahl

Sunday 28th of October 2018

Yep, start by standing right next to her and praise/treat while she's staying.

Julia at Home on 129 Acres

Sunday 28th of October 2018

You have it exactly right, Janis. Start very basic with no distractions and then work up to more complex environments. It takes practice for behaviours to translate to all situations. It sounds like you have a great start. Be patient and keep working!

Judy Weikum

Sunday 28th of October 2018

Thanks for training us!

Julia at Home on 129 Acres

Sunday 28th of October 2018

We're an equally important part of the equation!