Most Dogs Don’t Need a Fenced Yard

A fenced yard is convenient when you own a dog, but it’s not necessary.

Sometimes people who would like to adopt a dog think they need to have a house with a fenced yard first.

Sure, that would be nice, but it’s not a requirement. Dogs can get enough exercise in other ways. It’s OK to have a dog if you live in an apartment.

For example, Lindsay has never had a fenced yard as an adult. Her dog Ace never had a fenced yard and he got a lot of exercise, training, socialization and interaction without a yard. When he was younger, Lindsay dedicated even more time to exercising him. They often went running for an hour each morning.(2020 update: Ace has passed away.)

We both walk our dogs every day. This is something we would do with or without a yard. (Barbara does have a fenced yard and still walks her dogs of course!)

Most dogs don't need a fenced yard

Reasons why a fenced yard is not necessary for a dog

  • You can take some dogs to off-leash dog parks or beaches to run around.
  • Most dogs don’t use their yards for physical exercise unless someone is interacting with them. Instead, they sniff, pee on things, dig, take naps or patrol the fence.
  • You could hire a dog walker or runner to help you out if needed.
  • About one-third of people in the United States rent their housing, according to the National Multifamily Housing Council. Meanwhile, half of U.S. households have at least one dog, according to the Humane Society of the United States. I think we can assume plenty of dog owners are renters.
  • I would even argue that dogs without fenced yards actually get more exercise because their owners are more likely to walk them. These dogs are then more likely to be better socialized and better behaved in public, meaning they get to visit even more places. For example, in the top picture, my dog Ace is visiting a Mexican restaurant. In the second photo, he’s visiting a brewery.

*If you would like to receive our down-to-earth, weekly dog training tips, Click Here

Benefits of a fenced yard for dogs

Of course, a fenced yard is nice! It definitely has a certain convenience factor, especially as far as quick early morning and late night potty breaks are concerned, along with those on crappy weather days. Also, think about how easy it is to let your pup out into your fenced-in backyard when you’re sick like a dog, pun intended.

Potty training

The biggest benefit of a fenced-in yard would be potty training when you decide to bring home puppies or any other adult dog who’s not yet potty trained. It’s very simple and convenient to just open the back door and let your pup(py) take care of business as opposed to getting fully dressed, wear shoes, and leash your dog.

Don’t get me wrong, all this is doable too. Been there, done that when my two puppies Missy & Buzz moved in with me into a third floor apartment. We did countless trips up- and downstairs while I potty trained the puppies. However, I’d be lying if I said that a fenced-in backyard wouldn’t have been nice for the duration of our potty training.

Socialization

A fenced-in backyard also comes in handy when you’re planning doggy playdates for socialization purposes and to burn off some energy. Unlike at a dog park, you have control over which dogs your dog interacts with in your backyard.

It’s also easier to let your dog wrestle his friends and stretch their legs together outside as opposed to inside your home. There’s less chances of the pups breaking something and drooling all over the place in-between play breaks at the water bowl.

Fetch

Have you ever tried to play fetch with your dog inside your home? It’s not exactly ideal to say the least unless you’re looking to break a vase or similar fragile furnishing. That’s why being able to toss the ball or frisbee inside your fenced-in backyard is a winner! There, your pup will be able to stretch her legs and really give her all to get to her favorite fetch toy.

Freedom

Leash training is important and something I practice regularly, but every dog needs a break from it and appreciates just being able to roam around a bit off-leash. A fenced-in backyard is perfect for that kind of scenario, especially because you won’t have to worry about your pup taking off.

When my puppies and I lived in that third floor apartment, I invested in 50 ft long leashes for the purpose of letting them roam about on our apartment grounds. It worked fairly well, but obviously can’t be compared to the off-leash freedom of a fenced-in yard.

Time together

It’s fun to be able to spend time together with your family, particularly when the weather is nice enough to do so outside in your fenced-in backyard. Picture a BBQ and everyone just hanging out or lounging about on a sun chair. There’d be something missing if your dog wasn’t around for that, right?

Set up a pool

Dogs who love to splash around in the water will have a blast in their very own doggie pool that you set up in your fenced-in backyard. You won’t have to worry about potential rope burn or your dog tripping over his own leash or tie-out.

Practice agility

If you take your dog to agility classes, he’ll obviously be able to run the obstacle course in a secure area. But what about being able to practice in a similar setting in the privacy of your very own fenced-in backyard? Nothing beats that!

Just to recap, a fenced-in backyard is beneficial for these activities:

  • Potty training
  • Socialization
  • Playing fetch
  • Freedom
  • Time together
  • Setting up a pool
  • Agility practice

Cons to a fenced yard for dogs

However, a fenced yard can also come with a few downsides. The biggest issues result from leaving a dog outside in their fenced yard unsupervised for hours on end. That’s because the dog lacks mental stimulation and ends up getting bored.

Fence fighting

Neighbors who share a fence with dogs on either side often complain about fence fighting. It can start harmlessly with fence running but can ultimately result in frustrated dogs who snarl at each other and jump against the fence in an effort to get to the other dog.

Barking and digging

Dogs whose outside time is limited to their fenced yard only can become bored very quickly, especially if they’re young and full of energy. Excessive barking is one outlet for that pent-up energy, and digging is another one.

A backyard dog is the equivalent of a human stuck inside a small room. Can you imagine how incredibly bored you’d become after a few days of this?

Poop eating aka coprophagia

Gross to us, moderately to highly entertaining to our best friends! Poop eating can be another result of a bored dog who’s trying to come up with a fun pastime.

The easiest solution for this gross habit is to immediately pick up after your dog and not leave them outside unsupervised in the first place.

Escape artists

Some dogs are so bored in their fenced yards that they take matters into their own paws and figure out a way of escaping. Some will jump the fence while others will dig out under it. I remember going for walks in my old neighborhood with my Boxer mixes Missy and Buzz and frequently having a Husky tag along.

He was one of those backyard dogs who dug out under his fence on a very regular basis. He was harmless and not looking to get into trouble, but imagine what could have happened had he been aggressive towards other dogs and/or people.

Fence maintenance

Another downside of having a fenced-in yard is the fence maintenance. It’ll vary depending on the material of the fence of course. Wood fences will need boards replaced as they start to rot or break. Owners of dogs who like to dig under their fences regardless of the material will need to refill those holes and come up with solutions to prevent future digging related escapes.

One option might be lining the bottom of the fence with chicken wire, but honestly the easiest way to stop escape artists is to supervise their yard time and to offer mentally stimulating activities such as (backpack) walks, runs, or bike rides.

To recap, the downsides of a fenced-in yard are the following:

  • Brings out fence fighting
  • Other bad habits – barking, digging
  • Poop eating
  • Escape artists
  • Fence maintenance – replacing boards, covering holes

Some examples of happy apartment dogs

Amy from the blog Two Pitties in the City lives in Chicago with her husband and two adopted pitbulls (pictured below). Her blog is all about how easy it can be to live in a city and still have bigger dogs, even with no backyard.

She said taking her dogs on so many walks has helped expose her dogs to new situations such as parades and festivals. This has allowed Amy and her husband to do even more with their dogs, and she said the dogs are well trained and in great shape.

If they had a yard, Amy said she and her husband wouldn’t have the same type of connection they have with their dogs. She said she really enjoys the family time they have together while walking.

I also follow the blog We Live in a Flat, which features Donna the adopted mixed-breed dog who lives in an apartment in Singapore.

Donna loves to be outside for walks, where she gets to meet other dogs as well as sniff every patch of grass possible, her owner said.

The blog is partly about Donna’s owner learning to manage and train her dog to be “a good canine citizen in a high-density living environment.”

One of the great things about dogs is how easily they really do adapt to our lifestyles as long as we provide them with their basic needs.

Do you need a fenced yard to adopt a dog?

Some rescue groups and shelters in the United States require adopters to have fenced yards, but other groups look at dogs and families on a case-by-case basis.

If you’re trying to adopt a dog, keep looking until you find a rescue group that’s down to earth. Shelters are usually more flexible than rescue groups, and I wouldn’t rule out adopting a dog through Craigslist either.

Why do some rescue groups require a fenced yard?

Hi, Barbara here. I write for That Mutt regularly. Last year, I became a foster failure when I ended up adopting my now two-year old dog Wally from a rescue group. Their requirement for fostering and adopting a dog included having a house with a fenced-in backyard.

They didn’t do a home check in person, but did ask me to send in a video where I essentially took them on a virtual tour of my home, fenced-in yard included. Luckily I passed their virtual inspection and was approved both for fostering and adopting dogs.

There are several reasons for this policy:

  • We live in the countryside and unfortunately roaming dogs are a common sight.
  • Rescues want to ensure that the dogs they adopt out are safe, won’t end up getting run over or lost, and most importantly find their forever home. Of course the definition of “safe” depends on the perspective of the person using the word.
  • They’re aware that many people aren’t interested in taking their dogs for multiple daily walks.

Unfortunately, it’s not an ideal policy.

That’s because it disqualifies many great potential adopters from bringing a rescue dog home with them. “Oh I’m sorry, you don’t have a fenced-in yard? Move right along.” That judgement call is both frustrating and unfair. If a dog ends up stuck in a fenced-in yard all day long and frequently escapes, what’s the point of having a fenced-in yard, and is that dog truly safe?

If rescues were more flexible with their fence policy, they’d be able to adopt out more dogs than they currently do. They’d also stop contributing to the creation of bored yard dogs. Obviously they’ll still want to make sure that an adopter and the adopted dog are a good match, but there are other criteria that should matter besides a fence such as:

  • Does the potential adopter have references?
  • Do they make a good first impression?
  • How does the dog react to them?
  • Are they interested in taking the dog for a walk?
  • Do they seem physically fit if planning on adopting a high energy dog?
  • Do they have a support system in place such as a dog walker, neighbor or reliable family member if they work long hours?

To me, it seems like this check-list would still give rescue groups a good idea of who they’re dealing with and whether or not the potential adopter would be a good fit.

What kind of fence is best for a dog?

As far as which kind of fence works best for a dog, it really depends on the dog’s size and their owner’s budget and location as different material fences come with varying costs and maintenance needs. Certain neighborhoods with HOAs will also be able to dictate which type of fence can be installed. The different fence types are, from least to most expensive:

  • Chain link
  • Wooden
  • Vinyl
  • Metal/Aluminum

Vinyl and metal fences are more expensive upfront but require almost no maintenance. They’re also more visually appealing than chain link and wooden fences and are usually found in more upscale neighborhoods.

Vinyl and wooden fences offer the most privacy and can be beneficial for dogs who are easily triggered by anything that moves on the other side of their fence, including mail delivery services, kids on bikes, joggers, and other dogs.

Chain link fences are the cheapest, but also the least effective in securing a larger dog, especially if the dog is bored and prone to escaping. As a matter of fact, dogs who are determined can easily climb that type of fence!

Alternatives to a fence for your dog

If a physical fence isn’t an option, there are a few alternatives. These may work if the fence budget is extremely limited or if HOAs prohibit putting up an actual fence.

Invisible Fence

Invisible fences, also known as e-fences, are electric barriers that run underground. They keep a dog from crossing the electric boundary of their yard without the need of a physical fence.

However, dogs first need to be trained to respect the invisible fence. This in itself is the largest downside of an e-fence because you can’t just have it installed and expect your dog to know what to do. Other cons are:

  • It’s fairly expensive and can easily run upwards of $1000.
  • Requires your dog to wear a special battery operated collar that needs to be charged regularly.
  • It doesn’t keep other animals or people out of your yard.
  • It doesn’t deter a dog from exiting the yard if their prey drive is extremely strong. Those dogs will accept the momentary discomfort of being shocked.

See our posts on electronic fences for dogs:

Tie-out

Tie-outs are in-ground anchors or stakes that have a long cable or leash tied to them. The cable or leash are then attached to the dog’s collar or harness to keep him confined within the diameter of the tie-out.

They’re an inexpensive option of keeping a dog secured outside and can be taken along when you’re moving or camping. However, a dog’s who’s attached to a tie-out shouldn’t be left unsupervised. If he starts getting bored due to a lack of mental stimulation, he might very well start chewing on the cable or leash and break free in no time.

Large Ex-pen for puppies

Large ex-pens are a great way of keeping puppies confined to a certain area, both inside and outside. They’re sturdy and come in different sizes, so it’s highly unlikely that the puppies would be able to climb it or knock it over.

That being said, the little ones should still be supervised when they’re hanging out in an ex-pen. It’s a good idea to use an ex-pen if you’re busy around the house but are still able to check in on the puppies, for example when you’re cooking dinner or doing laundry.

Does YOUR dog have a fenced yard?

Let us know in the comments!

*If you like this article, we’d love to send you other helpful training tips in our weekly newsletter. Click Here.

45 thoughts on “Most Dogs Don’t Need a Fenced Yard”

  1. I agree that dogs without fenced yards often get more exercise and socialization! I have a small, fenced concrete patio bordered by dirt and mulch, which is great when the weather is bad or for that quick early morning potty break, but Ruby gets 1-3 walks per day also.

  2. Every house in our city built since the 60s has a fenced in yard. Owners can’t close escrow until the fence is in place. Good fences make good neighbors. But I agree that a fence is not a necessary requirement for owning a dog.

      1. Robert E Delaney

        My dog likes to run so I find it easier in the colder months to go outside and throw a ball. In the better weather I will definitely take him hikes and doggy parks.

  3. I agree that you don’t need a fenced yard. We have a small one for emergency potty breaks, that pretty much gets used in the winter only. Ours get walks and potty breaks a lot. The sad thing I see on Craigslist is people who live in apartments and can’t make the time to walk the dog and get it the exercise it needs. Why after 4 or 5 years of apartment living are you deciding it doesn’t work for the dog?? As a horse article said if you want more time for your horse, TURN OF THE TV!!!!

    Dogs are highly adaptable. We went from our comfortable routine to a hotel for 93 days and the only thing that really worried us was Belle loosing hair. After testing for everything we could think of, stress was what we came up with, after we moved into an apartment and settled into more of a routine she grew hair back in two months. While the place we are at has a nice big yard, there isn’t very good walking capabilities. So we hop in the truck and go places to go on walks and we play fetch and tug of war inside more. I must say both of my dogs are listening better and have more manners then they did 8 months ago. And its because of having them with us and making sure they knew what the proper behavior is when we are out and about.

    1. Lindsay Stordahl

      I’m glad you and the dogs are doing well after your stressful move and changes in living environments. That is hard on anyone.

  4. Saying that most dogs don’t need a fenced yard is a gross overstatement. Some dogs don’t need a fenced yard. Some dogs do. Your post feels like you are assuming that most people live in the same types of places you have and have dogs like Ace.

    If you ask me what percent need it, it comes down to more specific details – where you live (rural, suburban, urban), regional hazards, dog breed, background of dog if it’s an adult, etc.

    There are people who live in places where the dog must be leashed or tethered every single time it goes outside if there is no enclosure, due to the traffic or other hazards or due to the dog’s temperament. That’s not healthy.

    When you have a dog with a wonderful recall and no reactivity issues, it’s easy to forget that your recipe for success – leash them up for a run, go to the park/beach/trails, etc. – is not a suitable option for many other dogs. And even with a lot of training and experience, there are dogs who will never be safe outside off-leash or will always have some fears, sensitivities and reactivity issues that make people or dog populated areas difficult to navigate.

    I do agree that some people think the yard is the substitute for exercise, which is why I don’t like using “Do you have a fenced yard” as a proxy for “Will this dog get exercise.” Those are two entirely separate questions. But I think it’s a mistake to reassure people that they really don’t need a fenced yard without examining what conditions make the enclosed space more or less important based on the type of dog they are getting.

    1. Lindsay Stordahl

      I’m glad you disagree. It makes me think. Yes, my dog is extremely easy and can live almost anywhere.

      I guess I still believe most dogs do not need a yard. While writing this post I was trying to think of an example of a dog that absolutely must have a yard, and I could not think of one example. I still really can’t think of an example. People will often say certain types of dogs are escape artists and must have a fenced yard, but to me even those dogs would be better off without a yard so they wouldn’t have the opportunity to try to escape.

      Yes, a yard is definitely a great thing to have for dogs with poor social skills, aggression or terrible recalls.

      1. I think characterizing it as “poor social skills, aggression or terrible recalls” makes it sound like a black and white aspect, where the dog is defective or the owner is unwilling to train the dog. That’s unfair. Combinations of environment and breed/temperament can just be poorly suited for an unfenced life. I’ll also add that there is a big difference between living in an apartment or condo and living in a house on a large plot of land that happens to lack fencing. And it’s important to note that play is an important part of exercise for many dogs, which walking and running on leash does not provide.

        Otherwise, there are reasons some dogs benefit with fenced yards. Some dog breeds are prone to being territorial. This can manifest itself in all sorts of behavioral issues: guarding, barking, general reactivity. It was necessary for the tasks they were originally bred for. You can train around it but it’s still instinctive and if someone is adopting an adult dog, that boat has likely left the harbor. Even with dogs raised as puppies, when they reach adulthood, some can start to exhibit these characteristics, despite good breeding and training.

        If you have a fenced yard, it can make it much easier for the dog to learn the difference between outside territory that is theirs and outside territory that is not theirs. It is hard to imagine that this actually works if you are comparing relatively non-territorial dogs like labs and goldens to more territorial stranger-wary breeds like pyrenees, mastiffs, some types of terriers, rotties, Dobermans, ridgebacks, etc. But dogs that go on-leash outside for potty-breaks multiple times a day and only get their exercise by walking and running in their neighborhood can develop the sense that this running route or these bathroom locations are their entire territory, which can be more challenging to manage as a behavioral issue. In fact, moving to a place without a fenced yard for a territorial dog can make reactivity issues appear in a dog that didn’t really have them before. This is not uncommon for these types of dogs. It’s not just something that happens to poorly socialized or aggressive dogs. To the contrary, having an identifiable outdoor territory can make it easier to socialize and keep the good sociability in public going for some dogs who come from some of the most maligned breeds.

        Another reason for the fenced yard is that some dogs have too high prey drive to ever be reliable off-leash in an unfenced area, no matter what the training, especially if you live somewhere with small critters and traffic. And, again, dogs from some breeds are more prone to this behavior. Calling it a terrible recall is unfair because it takes a very high level of training, often from a young age, to override a high prey drive. With some dogs, no amount of training can do this (it’s a major reason why dogs bred to be service or guide dogs can still flunk out of the program & you can hardly blame the breeding or training!). Some people live in places with the type of traffic and prey to make it basically impossible (or gambling the dog’s life) to expect that to work out ok for that dog to be off-leash.

        This is also where “escape artist” becomes more of an issue because the outcome for the high prey drive dog prone to give chase is very different for the one whose instinct is to come back (hi, retrievers!) and the one whose chases turn into escapes (hi, huskies!). It’s extremely hard to imagine the level of management and training necessary to own one of these dogs.

        Also, some people just don’t live anywhere with appropriate off-leash areas to go. There might not be any off-leash trails or beaches. The only places might be off-leash dog parks, and those that exist may have too many people/dogs who shouldn’t be there to be safe. I’ve lived in this type of city before (thankfully, I don’t anymore). Some dog parks aren’t even fenced in themselves. Some dogs are not interested in playing with other dogs; they just want to be outside with their people. There just isn’t anywhere for them to go to chase a ball or play tug or chase a flirt pole or wrestle/chase a family/friend dog they know or whatever games they like.

        These are all dogs I’ve encountered in shelters, rescues, training classes, and the homes of people I know. They are purebreds and mixed breeds. These environments that lack genuinely good places to take a dog for exercise or to play are places I have lived before. The characteristics that make these dogs prone to chasing prey, getting hit by cars, reactivity to people, reactivity other dogs, reactivity to children, guarding/barking, etc. are often the reason that they wind up in training classes or, worse, shelters (and much much worse – injured or dead).

        Honestly, these reasons are a big part of why I am so much of a lab guy! I know my odds are so much smaller of having to deal with an unreliable off-leash dog or a territorial dog or an escape artist. (I still get to work with managing prey drive – hehe). But when I’m trying to help someone find a dog or help someone keep the dog they already have or trying to help a dog find a family, it would be disingenuous to act like the problem is that the dog isn’t lab enough and the owner isn’t good enough at training their dog.

        Telling people how a fenced yard can help them and which types of dogs might be better suited for them if they don’t have one is an important part of the process. I think suggesting that most dogs and owners won’t need (or greatly benefit) from a fenced yard is the same type of overgeneralization as requiring everyone have the fenced yard in the first place.

        1. Lindsay Stordahl

          Sean, you raise some great points. I can see what you are saying. Thank you for bringing these up.

          I think I will always be pretty passionate about my belief that you just don’t need a yard for most dogs, but nothing in the dog world is black and white and I’m really glad you brought up all of these issues. I’m really thinking about everything you said, and I’m curious to hear what others have to say too.

        2. My dog is great pyrenees/husky across. He is territorial/high prey drive/most things you mentioned. I do not have a yard. I wish I did but I don’t. His reactivity with people in the hall of my building is escalating. You brought up some good points that I didn’t think about. I moved to Vancouver, BC from a 10 acre property which borders crown land. It is very hard to find pet friendly housing in this city and although I am constantly looking for a pet friendly place with a yard it is entirely out of my budget. I lucked out and found a place for us in a co-op which didn’t even ask for a deposit. Do you have any advice on how to approach him thinking that the hallway is an extension of my apartment. I treat when I see a person approach but as the hallways are narrow it is far too close to threshold.

          1. Lindsay Stordahl

            Hi Kelly. Sorry to hear about your dog’s reactivity. That is a great question. I just started writing a response about similar experiences I have had, but my tips were just about ways I’ve controlled the reactivity (working on calm obedience in the doorway, using extremely valuable treats for working on “watch me” etc.) I haven’t thought about how to get the dog to think differently about the hallway being an extension of the apartment. That is a great question. I’m hoping some others can chime in.

          2. I don’t think you can convince a dog that the hallway isn’t part of the same “house.” That’s not really how dogs relate to property and territory, especially when so much of how dogs are trained and taught is based on inside vs. outside distinctions, like potty training. If hallways and lobbies have the same floor surface as our apartments & require the same behavioral rules, it is completely logical for our dogs to assume that our apartment is one set of “rooms” in a bigger “house.” To really differentiate, you’d have to have a larger set of differences between inside your apartment and outside in the hallway, I think.

            As to what you can do, treating for a good behavior when you’re around people in the building, like you’re doing, is good.

            You can introduce the game “Look at me” or “What’s that?” (dog looks at person, then back at you) in a different less stressful place and then add it in the hallway with people at further distance away. You may need friends or neighbors to help out as decoys set up at proper distance down hallway. This way the reactivity trigger becomes the training game for counter-conditioning.

            If you know neighbors or feel comfortable, your best bet is probably to get your dog to meet them in better circumstances (invite them to your apartment if your dog is good with that, maybe meet totally outside the building if that’s more successful, etc.) and then encounter the same people again with treats in the narrow hallway in a planned way. This works because the dog will expand his realm of who “belongs” in your territory. He won’t stop thinking the hallways is his, but it becomes “ours” because these same people he knows and sees a few times (and have hot dogs and cheese or whatever sometimes!) are part of his extended living group. I know that can be hard when you live in a big city and don’t even know your neighbors, though. But for dogs who have a clearer sense of family/friends vs. strangers, it can help to have them expand their pool of who is not a stranger.

            Another thing that could help just for managing the situation as you work on the training is to have your dog wear a bright vest that says “Please give me space” or “Dog in training.” Some people will see that and give a wider berth for you with your dog in the building.

            Hope these ideas help!

    2. I have more a question than a comment.We live in a large 4 bedroom/3bathroom house in a suburb,unfortunately we have a small influenced yard. My question is would a Shellie be happy here,being that they are a herding breed?

      1. Dang spell check will not let me correct okay no fence ( not allowed by township rules ) dog breed is Shetland sheepdog not shellie

  5. We are lucky enough to have a fenced yard, although I agree it’s not essential. The most important time is that late night pee break or middle of the night upset stomach.

  6. We don’t have a fenced yard, and our dog is fine. I would also like to point out, after reading one of the above comments, that my dog has terrible reactivity issues, including leash aggression and fear aggression directed towards strangers. If I had a yard it would be nothing more than a convenient excuse for me to dump him in it and not deal with the problem. As it is, I have to walk him every day, and I take him lots of places. His fear problems are so so much better than they used to be. He even got the highest score on the final exam in our obedience class. My dog gets plenty of opportunities to run and be “free” even though we don’t have a yard. We take him jogging and to dog parks. There are even private dog parks if your dog has problems with other dogs (see Zoom Room). I think whether a dog “needs” a yard depends more on the type of person than type of dog.

    1. Lindsay Stordahl

      Great example. Thank you for chiming in. I’ve fostered some reactive dogs that couldn’t go to dog parks, and I was able to find ways to exercise, train and socialize them without a yard too. I did have the benefit of large open areas, where I could take the dog out on a long, long rope to run around. That helped a lot.

      I think Sean has some great points. I would find it very difficult to live with a highly aggressive/reactive dog in my current apartment space, for example. It wouldn’t be impossible, but it would be challenging and stressful. We have narrow hallways with narrow stairs and lots of dogs around. Other owners allow their dogs to be out ahead on Flexi leashes, and it would be challenging to keep a highly aggressive dog safe from trouble just while going out for frequent potty breaks. There are also kids running around.

      Perhaps the best thing to take from all of this is that every situation is unique. As you said, it may be more about the type of person and how experienced and willing he/she is than the type of dog. Great point!

      1. First, kudos to Jessica for the great work with your reactive/fearful dog. Glad it’s gotten so much better.

        I agree that some people with a yard would be tempted to dump the dog in the yard and never deal with reactivity issues. That’s a big problem. The dog’s world gets smaller and smaller, and the behavior problems get worse.

        At the same time, the best way to desensitize and counter-condition dogs is to be able to control their exposure to triggers. A dog living in the state of stress and anxiety due to circumstances like Lindsay’s apartment would be extremely challenging to work with. You can have lots of successful training and outing undermined by bad daily or weekly experiences with other people living in your apartment who just don’t get it. And the dog has to go out for potty at SOME time, not always before 5:30 AM and after 10:00 PM. The dog is stressed, the people are stressed.
        It’s selfish to deliberately place a dog in an environment that the dog experiences as constant stress without the likelihood of being able to alleviate that stress. But, of course, there is a difference between apartment life (or more specifically busy apartment complex life) and the issue of fenced yards.

  7. We second that opinion and would also add that because you live in an apartment does not mean you can’t have a larger dog. In Europe, Mom had a lab/newf mix in an apartment, no problem. My Kuvasz sister Katie also lived in an apartment her first two years. We love our yard because we play chase and wrestle out there and it is nice to lay in the grass on a beautiful day, but Our exercise comes from walks and other adventures. The same is true with an apartment, if you exercise the dog, it doesn’t matter. The people that need the yard are the ones that don’t walk their dog and need a place to use as a bathroom. That is out take!

  8. We are in the process of putting up fencing now. It is for a supervised yard, so we will be interacting with the dogs. I do agree that many dogs without fences get more exercise and socialization than those with fences.

  9. I finally live in a home with a fenced yard! However, until this past year I lived in a condo with the dogs without a fenced yard. Living in the condo with Linus and Stetson was great and we never had any problems not having a yard. I must say that we did go on more walks when we lived in the condo.

  10. This is perfect and I will be sharing! I hear people say all the time that they can’t have a dog because they don’t have a yard, or they only exercise their dogs in the yard, or they’re so happy they have a yard for their dog. I have LOTS of conversations along the same lines as your post.

    I was very impressed when a shelter in small city in the Bay Area united with the police department and educated dog owners about what they termed “back yard syndrome.” It’s when dogs are only exposed to the back yard and they lose their health while gaining weight, lose their socialization and become territorial, etc. It was a great effort – I think they stopped a few years back but it was really impressive!

    1. Lindsay Stordahl

      Thanks so much for sharing my post. I also hear people say they wish they had a yard so they could get a dog. While some dogs may do better with a yard, there are plenty of dogs that don’t need one. If someone lives in an apartment and wants a dog, there are plenty of good dogs to choose from.

      Great to hear the Bay Area was educating people on “back yard syndrome.”

  11. This is a really good point! I’ve got a back yard (which I totally love and always want to go out to ‘check’ on the squirrels), but I also love to go out with Mum- We go and pick Cosmo up from his house next door and walk all over the neighborhood, we know so many people because we’re out and about!

    I hope you’re having a fun day,

    Your pal Snoopy 🙂

  12. In Singapore, about 82% of people living in public housing that are flats. You could say we don’t have the mentality that we need a yard to get a dog simply because most people don’t expect to get the privilege of having one. Dogs get walked on the streets and in the parks, which is great because they meet a lot more people and other dogs that way : )

  13. Robin Bjerken

    We have a yard with a fence around part of it. You are right, my dogs would never get enough exercise in our backyard. But it is good when you can just let them out to do their job and not worry about them, sometimes they like to go lay on the deck in the summer and although they have a great recall, I can go in the house and not worry about them wandering and still have a watchful eye on them. But agreed, you can work it out without a yard.

  14. I’m the owner of two whippets and currently in the process of looking for a rental. The area I am looking to rent in is mostly apartments and condos with no yard, of course my dogs need their daily walks. At the same time I’m trying to figure out how to do bathroom breaks without a fenced yard? Whippets are very social and non aggressive but they tend to dart off quite quickly. So how do you do middle of the night potty breaks without putting your dogs at risk? Both my dogs are used to a fenced in area and won’t go to the bathroom on a leash. How to I make the transisition to apartment living. Do people train their dogs to use a balcony area? Any help or advice would be so appreciated. Lindsey

    1. Lindsay Stordahl

      For dogs that aren’t used to going on a leash, sometimes using a longer leash/rope helps or even a retractable leash. Other than that, it’s just going back to basics and rewarding them for peeing while on the leash. I’m sure they’ll catch on eventually.

  15. I have a large blue heeler mix in a condo – lol. I can’t think of too many breeds that could be worse in a condo. I was lucky enough to have him as a puppy though and he’s been well socialized and even attends dog day camp once or twice a week. I also have fields nearby where he can get some running in. My previous dog was a pit bull and also lived in the condo.

    TBH, the people I know with large dogs in condos get them out much more often than the yarded ones. Also, about folks giving away dogs on craigslist – most of the adds I read it seems like the people had a yard but their kids don’t show interest/etc.

  16. I am a volunteer with a breed Rescue and have fostered dogs. While a fenced yard is preferred, adopting out a dog is left to the foster parent. I have adopted out dogs to families that do not have fenced yards or live in an apartment. As long as the person/family understand that sufficient exercise is necessary for the mental and physical health of the dog and have made arrangements for owners providing exercise, doggie day care or a neighbor giving the dog an extra walk. A tired dog is a good dog!!

  17. Fences are as much to keep other dogs OUT as our dogs IN. I’m in Houston and the number of free-roaming, untrained, un-fixed and unvaccinated dogs is horrifying. They frequently roam in packs, attacking others, and causing massive damage. Give me a fenced yard every time.

  18. So an issue rarely covered by any training blogs. “Farm/Country” dogs.
    I live in the middle of a 100 acre woods. I want a dog who’s job is to keep the “critters” out of the yard-deer, coyotes, raccoons, etc. Of course, the dog would have indoor access, especially during the cold weather months. But ideally, he would be outside 24/7 as many, if not most critters come during the overnight hours.
    So how does one teach the dog to stay “in the yard”? My last outdoor dog had the bad habit of going to visit our other farm neighbors – no one really wants someone else’s dog at their home. They learned who she belonged to & would call for us to pick her up.
    Fencing the yard or invisible fence isn’t a realistic option. Suggestions?

  19. I have to have a fenced in your for my Malinois. I agree with the other poster who said it is to keep the dog in and other dogs/wildlife out. I have a wooded wetland with a creek as my neighbor behind me and the deer/coyotes/feral cats are everywhere! We also had a skunk “issue” a few years ago. I love my 6ft vinyl privacy fence. It is perfect for frisbee a match and made potty training a breeze.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *